Britain’s Got Talent has once again been caught in a “fix” controversy after viewers accused Simon Cowell 

of pretending not to recognize a contestant who had previously appeared on America’s Got Talent just two years ago. 

Fans were quick to call out the apparent inconsistency after stunt performer Auzzy Blood took to the stage with his jaw-dropping and gruesome act.

Auzzy Blood Stuns and Horrifies Audiences

During the latest episode of Britain’s Got Talent, Auzzy Blood—a gothic cabaret stuntman—left both the judges and audience gasping with his extreme performance. 

The Las Vegas-based performer showcased a series of dangerous stunts, 

including pushing a giant screw through his mouth and nose before lifting himself into the air with a hook embedded in his jaw.

The gruesome act proved too much for judge Alesha Dixon, who hit her buzzer early, admitting that she simply “couldn’t watch it.” However, Simon Cowell, Amanda Holden, and Bruno Tonioli were captivated by the shocking display and voted to send Auzzy through to the next round.

Despite the judges’ reactions, fans were left unconvinced—especially after Simon Cowell claimed that he had “never seen anything like it before.” Viewers were quick to point out that Auzzy had appeared on America’s Got Talent in 2022, where Cowell was also a judge.

Viewers Call Out Simon’s ‘Fake’ Surprise

Eagle-eyed fans of the Got Talent franchise immediately took to social media to call out the apparent contradiction. Many pointed out that Simon had been a judge during Auzzy’s AGT audition, making it unlikely that he genuinely had no memory of the performer.

One YouTube commenter noted:

“The funniest thing for me was Simon acting like he never saw this guy before—he was on America’s Got Talent two years ago, and Simon was a judge!”

Another viewer added:

“Simon has become a really good actor at this point.”

Some long-time fans of the show accused Britain’s Got Talent of frequently featuring performers who had already appeared on other versions of the franchise, yet presenting them as if they were unknown talents.

“Simon has done this many times—Piff the Magic Dragon, Tape Face, Wes P, Gonzo, to name a few. The show is staged,” one frustrated viewer wrote.

Others pointed to past instances where established performers had participated in BGT under the guise of being newcomers. They argued that the show has a history of featuring professional acts, despite being presented as a platform for undiscovered talent.

Auzzy Blood’s History in the Got Talent Franchise

Auzzy Blood, whose real name is Austin Punton, has already made a name for himself across multiple versions of the Got Talent series. He first appeared on America’s Got Talent in 2022, where he showcased his daring sword-swallowing skills. His act included hammering a steel beam into his mouth before inviting judge Howie Mandel to help push a knife down his throat.

Although Auzzy made it through to the later stages of the competition, he was ultimately eliminated in the wildcard round.

His BGT performance, however, saw him elevate his stage persona, adopting a menacing silent demeanor with an eerie grin and an unsettling laugh. Unlike his AGT audition, where he interacted with the judges, Auzzy refrained from speaking during his British audition, instead responding to questions with intense stares.

Auzzy is far from the only performer to have participated in multiple Got Talent franchises. He has also competed in Spain’s Got Talent, where he reached the finale by inserting hooks into his eyelids, as well as France’s Got Talent.

Are Professional Performers Unfairly Favored?

While some fans believe that featuring professional acts on BGT creates an unfair advantage, the show’s rules do not prohibit contestants from appearing even if they have competed in other versions of the franchise.

A source close to the show previously told The Sun that performers with past experience do not necessarily hold an unfair edge, as the final decision still rests with the public vote.

“The show has never hidden the fact that auditions are open to everybody, irrespective of previous experience. Everybody is given the same opportunity on the show,” the source explained.

The insider further emphasized that while some contestants may have had previous exposure, they are still not widely known to the British audience.

“Regardless of experience, these contestants are not household names and are unknown to most of the public. The show offers contestants an opportunity to perform on a global scale and pursue their dreams.”

Fans Remain Divided

Despite Britain’s Got Talent maintaining that the competition is fair, many viewers remain skeptical, particularly when judges react as though they are seeing certain performers for the first time.

For some, the issue is less about whether professionals are allowed to compete and more about the show’s presentation—especially when someone like Simon Cowell, who has been a judge across multiple Got Talent franchises, feigns surprise.

As the debate continues, one thing is clear: Auzzy Blood’s performance has certainly left a lasting impression—both for his shocking stunts and the latest controversy surrounding Britain’s Got Talent’s authenticity.

Follow us to see more useful information, as well as to give us more motivation to update more useful information for you.